Tracking down former Dog Borstal inmates, six months after their short, sharp shock, Mic spies on dog and owner to see if they’ve settled back into bad habits. At the end of the show, Mic inspects the offender’s home to look for incriminating evidence!

Mic loves playing up to his hard-man image but clearly wants what he believes to be best for the dog. This should be an interesting series and will no doubt answer the question each of us has at the end of a Dog Borstal episode: will they keep it up?

Don’t forget the Dog Borstal thread on the Dogs Rule forums!

While Huey and Caspar won the audience’s hearts, when it came down to the final two it was Selina and Chump who were able to jump through the hoops set by the show.

From the beginning of the show, it was clear that Selina and Chump had developed a great relationship and that he loved to work with her. It’s just such a shame that Selina feels unable to adopt Chump.

Huey clearly felt that Caspar’s progress hadn’t been appreciated by the judges. When he chose not to take part in the dog dancing, saying that Caspar needed more time to reach that stage, the judges were not impressed.

At times, it seemed as though the judges – more used to the world of professional dog shows – had unreasonable expectations of these wonderful rescue dogs. Is Peter Purves really that harsh, or is he just taking on the bad-guy role?

The Underdog Show was great fun and highlighted the plight of the thousands of dogs abandoned in rescue centres across the country. It seems strange that income from the phone voting went to Children In Need, rather than the Dogs Trust. The Dogs Trust was heavily involved in the show and seems to be the natural choice of charity to benefit from any voting income.

Let’s hope The Underdog Show returns for another series. Next time, perhaps they’ll consider a more appropriate charity to benefit from voting income and introduce some more elements to really demonstrate the joy of life with rescue dogs.

Chat about The Underdog Show in our new forums!

The show pairs eight rescue dogs from The Dogs Trust’s West London rehoming centre with eight celebrities. Each week, the dogs and celebs undergo increasingly difficult obedience and agility tasks, with their performance rated both by a panel of expert judges and the viewers at home. Sadly, the pair with the lowest score is evicted from the show each week.

The first episode of The Underdog Show was great fun! Unlike Dog Borstal, which focuses on the failings of owners, and the somewhat cynical Help! My Dog’s as Fat as Me, it summed up what’s so great about living with dogs.

Each of the eight dogs displayed huge amounts of character, leaving the celebrities somewhat in the shade. Throughout the tasks, the dogs were clearly having fun, even if the celebrities were occasionally frustrated.

Julian Clary presents the show and is accompanied by his dog Valerie. It’s good to see a presenter who is well known for their love of dogs.

Overall, particularly thanks to the involvement of The Dogs Trust, The Underdog Show is a great way to show the wider public that rescue dogs make fantastic companions. Let’s hope one or two viewers give a home to a dog in need.

Chat about The Underdog Show in our new forums!

Rob Alleyne, author of The Trouble-Free Dog and trainer on Dog Borstal, tells us about his approach to dog training and his experience of working on the BBC 3 show.

How did you become a professional dog trainer?

I used to attend a dog training class with my own dog 20+ years ago. Then the woman who ran it decided to retire and offered it to me. I was only 19 or 20 and was terrified at the prospect, but reluctantly agreed rather than see the class close. And I have run classes ever since.

Like most good trainers, I develop by studying what I am doing, and looking to see how it can be improved. There are few truly wrong methods per se that should never be used, though there are many that are used inappropriately. I also look at things that other people do, and use them or modify them to suit my situation or client if necessary.

Learning is an ongoing process, there are things that I do now that I won’t be doing in five years, and there are things that I did five years ago that I can’t believe I did or told people to do. But that is how we learn.

Where did the idea for Dog Borstal come from?

Apparently the idea was thought up by the programme’s Executive Producer, after fostering a rescue dog that would have otherwise had major, though unnecessary, surgery.

How did you become involved in Dog Borstal?

I received a phone call asking me if I thought that it could be done, and if I thought that I could do it? The rest, as they say, is history.

Is your fellow Dog Borstal trainer, Mic Martin, as scary as he seems on tv?

Only if you cross him. Actually, he really isn’t that scary at all. He gives a lot of himself when training, and he asks a lot in return. People who aren’t prepared to do that get it in the neck, and he makes no apologies for that.

To be honest, prior to meeting Mic, I was convinced that I would absolutely hate him, But in fact we get on really well. People have accused him of all sorts, that he’s homophobic, sexist, and a bully. Watching him on television, I can completely see why people would think that. But what people forget when watching these programmes is that for every minute that you see, there are probably three hours that you didn’t see.

As an example, everyone thought that he was horrible to Billie-Jean last week for no reason at all. In fact, she turned up an hour and a half late for filming, keeping the whole crew waiting, and apparently, her only excuse was that she had stopped on the hard shoulder for that long as Fudge needed to get it on with Shag Teddy, which she thought was very funny. Needless to say, Mic was not impressed, and what you saw was the immediate aftermath.

And Dale from the first show told the other students that he only came on because he wanted to be on television, and had no real desire to train his dog. Nobody notices how encouraging Mic is when it is going well, or how much he supports the dogs though, which is a shame.

Why do you think dogs and humans live and work together so well?

Because we are so similar in so many ways, and yet so different in others. They make very good dogs, but very poor people, and my clients are usually people who have forgotten this.

What’s your main tip for people who have recently taken on a puppy or adult dog?

Treat it as the family dog from the time you bring it home. It is not a new baby, it is a new puppy, and although there may be some similarities, it is governed by some very different rules from a human child.

Educate it primarily on how to do the right thing. It will learn so much more quickly if you take the time to show it the right way to do things, rather than waiting for it to do the wrong thing and then punish it. Look at all of the things that you are letting it do as a puppy. If you would not be happy for him/her to do them as an adult, stop it now, and show it what it should be doing instead.

Do you have dogs?

I have a five year old German Shepherd named Jester. Never was a dog more appropriately named, he is such a clown.

Read our review of BBC 3’s Dog Borstal or buy Rob’s book The Trouble-Free Dog.

Chat about Dog Borstal in our forums.

Making the most of its disused air base location – high wire fences, military-style tents for the owners and cages for the mutts – the show gives the owners a short, sharp shock.

The first episode introduced the trainers: Debbie Connolly, Rob Alleyne and Mic Martin. So far, Debbie and Rob seem like normal people; Mic seems to enjoy his position of power a touch too much, though.

As a former police dog trainer, and with tales of his military service never far from his lips, Mic likes to make it clear he’s a man’s man. Sadly, the producers thought it necessary to engineer a little conflict and placed him with Flake, a Jack Russell whose gay owners inspired a series of nervous, “what they do in the privacy of their own home is their business” style comments from tough-guy Mic.

The first show’s other two inmates were Henry – a Weimeraner whose main hobby was stopping his owner from putting a jumper on – and Maggie, a Staffie who was still terrorising her neighbourhood despite having mauled a smaller dog and killed two cats.

Although Mic’s hard-man act was somewhat tedious, the trainers quickly demonstrated their expertise. Henry’s boistrous behaviour and strong will were quickly brought under control and Maggie was able to resist sinking her teeth into any other animal that walked past.

It appears that Dog Borstal could be of more long-term interest than Channel 4’s It’s Me or The Dog. We’ve stopped watching Victoria Stillwell’s show, mainly because it has become a little samey now it’s in the second series. Dog Borstal, although contrived in places, is perhaps fresher.

Chat about Dog Borstal in our forums.